Nostro Posto Pizzeria & Ristorante

Reviews

• Mitch K.

  star star star star star 12 June 2026

  Absolutely amazing.
  I had what seemed to be a new server to their team come to our table, and when she spoke I knew she wasn't new. Mary was my server, however Susan brought my Martini over and it was perfect. My wife and I come in once a week. And Friday night was just different. It was nice to see people working together as a team. Even the boy collecting plates seemed new. I look forward to coming back again. .
  By the way, I usually send my Martini back because they don't do it right, my Martini was as I said before, Perfect.
  Thank you for an enjoyable evening.

• Michael S.

  star star star star star_border 12 June 2026

  Nostro Postro is the typical Italian restaurant that you'll find in any NY neighborhood outside of the city.  Comfortable, welcoming, and a smorgasbord of Italian goodness!
  
  The cool concept of this one is the front has the typical pizzeria restaurant, while the back end is the typical neighborhood Italian sit down experience!
  
  The bread that's brought to the table is really good!  The wine list is very fair in price, but short on options.
  My go-to in NY for these spots is the traditional Chicken Parmesan!  A large breast that's been pounded out thin, breaded, deep fried, smothered in cheese, and served with a heaping mound of pasta!  Though I devoured it without taking pictures, let that fact alone be the reason to trust me on this being a must try!

• Benjamin K.

  star star star star star_border 9 June 2026

  I've now been here several times and am pretty happy with this place. The pizza is good. The service is good. The location is nice and clean. If you're looking for a slice, it's solid, regardless of type of slice; they have plenty of options for pizza and kitchen food. A good option for pizza/Italian in the area.

• Gary G.

  star star star star star 30 May 2026

  We usually come here about twice a month.  It's a hidden gem in an absolutely dead shopping center.
  
  The pizza is amazing and every entree we have tried has been delicious.  The owners and staff bend over backward to make sure that you are comfortable and happy.
  
  Highly recommended!

• Meri L.

  star star star star star_border 21 May 2026

  I was very "on the fence" about trying this place, as it's brand new to the neighborhood and I've seen a ton of places come and go in the very location that Nostro Posto is in now. I'm happy I got off that fence tonight.
  
  My boyfriend and I decided to order out as we both had a long miserable Monday at work and neither of us wanted to cook or do the dishes. We wanted to try a few things just to test them out. We got a pie well done with half pepperoni, 1/2 dozen garlic knots and penne ala vodka.
  
  The pizza was great. They didn't put a lot of sauce, but that's okay! I don't like my pizza overly saucy. I just wish the pepperoni was more evenly distributed on the half of pizza. Some slices had a whole bunch, while others had only a few pieces.
  
  Garlic knots were basic garlic knots, but full of flavor. We also got an extra one...only ordered 1/2 dozen and got 7! Perhaps one for good luck?
  
  Penne ala vodka was wonderful. The vodka sauce was truly exceptional. I love that some bread was included because I enjoy dipping some bread in to soak up the sauce.
  
  Tonight was a carb overload for my boyfriend and I, but it was delicious! We also have leftovers for tomorrow.
  
  Service was great when I went inside to pick up the order. I felt welcomed. However, when I placed the order, the girl on the phone could have been a little friendlier.
  
  They also seem to have a points system. Perhaps to earn free food? At the bottom of my receipt tonight it stated I earned 34 points.
  
  I will be back to try something else. Perhaps sit in next time to have the full experience.